Ted Butler Quote of the Day 11-15-14

A little while back, I commented that I believed the big drop in the price of crude oil, by far the most important commodity in the world, was set off by futures positioning on the NYMEX and other derivatives trading exchanges. Specifically, I concluded that selling by technically motivated traders over the past few months was most responsible for the sharp drop in the price of crude oil, as well as the not coincidental price drops in silver, gold, copper, palladium and platinum.  I gave the documented quantities of contracts and equivalent amounts of material that were sold and can do so again on request.

What I have seen unfold over the past 40 years has been a steady progression of futures trading overwhelming actual supply and demand as the prime influence on price. I’m not suggesting that actual supply and demand don’t matter to price, just that they have been pushed aside for extended periods by the influence of derivatives positioning. I discovered it in COMEX silver nearly three decades ago and have seen it creep into most markets currently. What I am saying is that in the “old days” (30 to 40 years ago) it was strictly supply and demand that determined price; but that we have evolved into a modern era of derivatives trading overwhelming actual supply and demand as the prime price influence.

A small excerpt from Ted Butler’s subscription letter on 11-12-14.

  More precious metals news & information available at
Ed Steer’s Gold & Silver Daily.